@ruza: you're right. I would like to know about both positive and negative votes. I won't consider Uservoice for our projects because although it's interesting it's just not balanced enough.
@chaiguy1337: Yes, commenting is good but it means a developer has to wade through all the comments, and even then that still doesn't give a true and fair representation of the community's opinions.
The slashdot system works well - most votes are positive even though negative votes are allowed. A system that does not allow User Voices to outline the negative impacts of an idea is fundamentally flawed to the extent where it is not properly representative. As for setting tone, there are other ways to achieve this.
LOL @ metavida - if your posts don't make the point about allowing editing of posts I don't know what will!
3 Allow editing of suggestions - 8 days ago
@ruza: you're right. I would like to know about both positive and negative votes. I won't consider Uservoice for our projects because although it's interesting it's just not balanced enough.
@chaiguy1337: Yes, commenting is good but it means a developer has to wade through all the comments, and even then that still doesn't give a true and fair representation of the community's opinions.
3 allow negative votes? - 22 days ago
The slashdot system works well - most votes are positive even though negative votes are allowed. A system that does not allow User Voices to outline the negative impacts of an idea is fundamentally flawed to the extent where it is not properly representative. As for setting tone, there are other ways to achieve this.
3 allow negative votes? - 24 days ago
An absolute must!
3 allow negative votes? - 3 months ago